In today’s food industry, understanding how General Liability Insurance and Product Recall Insurance work together is essential, yet it’s often misunderstood. Both coverages play critical yet distinct roles in protecting food companies from financial and reputational damage.
Since the introduction of the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) of 2011, companies that manufacture, process, or distribute food products have been required to maintain a written recall plan. This shift from reactionary to preventive regulation has led many businesses, either by mandate or by prudence, to purchase Product Recall Insurance.
Even as more food companies adopt recall coverage, confusion still exists about how General Liability/Product Liability Insurance and Product Recall Insurance interact. Understanding the distinction between the two can make the difference between an effective risk management strategy and significant uninsured exposure.
General Liability: Protection After Harm Occurs
General Liability Insurance, which includes Products Liability, is the cornerstone of any insurance program in the food industry. It’s often required by customers, distributors, and retailers before they will do business with you.
In simple terms, General Liability covers a company when an event has already caused harm, such as bodily injury, illness, or property damage, to a third party like your customer or your customer’s customer.
For example, if your product causes foodborne illness or damages another company’s finished product, your General Liability policy responds to those third-party claims.
Product Recall: Coverage when Harm or Damage is Imminent
Product Recall Insurance responds when there is a reasonable likelihood that your product could cause harm.
This coverage reimburses your company for the costs of removing, destroying, and replacing potentially unsafe products. It’s designed to protect your business, not your customers, from the financial consequences of contamination or defect before bodily injury or property damage has occurred.
Typical recall expenses include:
- Loss of income from recalled product
- FDA notification and regulatory coordination
- Customer notification and product retrieval
- Disposal and destruction costs
- Crisis management and reputational repair
As outlined in several Coughlin Insurance Services insights, recall events can be financially devastating. Even a small-scale recall can easily reach six figures once lost product, logistics, testing, and brand recovery are taken into account.
Case Study: When Both Coverages Are Triggered
To illustrate how these coverages interact, consider a real-world example handled by Coughlin Insurance Services.
Imagine this scenario: a food importer (“XYZ Food Company”) brought in three containers of dried fruit from a foreign supplier, totaling roughly $2 million in product. The company distributed the fruit to four customers for use in finished goods such as granola and chocolate blends.
Shortly afterward, one customer reported finding plastic fragments in their finished product. Testing confirmed that the contamination originated from the imported dried fruit.
Because XYZ Food Company carried both General Liability and Product Recall Insurance, they immediately notified Coughlin Insurance, who guided them through the claims process and coordinated with both insurance carriers.
The Product Recall carrier assisted with:
- Notifying the FDA and affected customers
- Organizing a voluntary recall
- Overseeing retrieval and disposal of contaminated stock
- Managing crisis communications to protect brand reputation
The General Liability policy responded to third-party claims involving:
- Bodily injury from consumption of contaminated goods
- Property damage to other products containing the fruit (such as granola and chocolate)
- Customer loss of income and additional operating costs
The outcome resulted in Product Recall coverage that paid approximately $800,000, as well as General Liability coverage that paid approximately $1,000,000.
This example highlights how both coverages complement each other, as well as how having each in place can prevent a single incident from turning into a business-threatening loss.
Why Experience Matters
Coordinating between recall and liability carriers can be complex. Expenses, timelines, and responsibilities often overlap, requiring careful documentation and communication.
An experienced food-industry insurance specialist plays a vital role in helping companies understand which policy responds to which expense; navigate the claims process efficiently; maintain compliance with regulatory requirements, and preserve customer relationship and brand reputation.
At Coughlin Insurance Services, our team works with more than 240 food companies across the country, helping them design coverage programs that minimize exposure and ensure swift, coordinated responses when incidents occur.
The relationship between General Liability and Product Recall Insurance is not “either/or” – It’s “both/and.”
Together, they create a comprehensive safety net that protects your customers, your brand, and your bottom line.
Understanding that intersection, and partnering with an agent who specializes in the food industry, ensures that your company is prepared for both the unexpected event and the preventable crisis.
Since 1947, Coughlin Insurance Services has strived to find ways to protect customers’ lives, have their backs and provide our special brand of service. As we evolved, we have expanded our offerings from personal insurance solutions like homeowners and auto insurance, to business and commercial insurance, including insurance for food manufacturers and contractors. To learn how we can help you, click here.
.
